Ruling could help businesses but hurt landlords

Businesses that lease offices in converted houses may now be able to buy the freehold at reduced rates following a court ruling. Peter Sutherland explains how the decision could be bad news for landlords but an unexpected gift for their tenants.

The simple question of "what is a house?" could be worth millions of pounds to Nottinghamshire landlords and their commercial tenants.

It's important because the law allows tenants in blocks of flats to get together and exercise their right to collective enforcement. This is a legal mechanism that allows them to buy the freehold of their homes on favourable terms as long as there is a majority in favour.

It usually applies to private tenants but recently three small businesses who leased offices in converted town houses argued that it should apply to them as well. They knew that if they succeeded they would be able to buy at prices way below the going rate on the open market.

The tenants argued that the buildings they occupied were still essentially houses and sought to exercise their right to collective enfranchisement under the Leasehold Reform Act 1967.

The landlords objected saying the Act did not apply in this case because the buildings were used exclusively for business purposes.

The case went all the way to the Court of Appeal which has ruled in favour of the tenants. Lord Neuberger said the definition of house could "extend to buildings exclusively used for business purposes".

He said: "Once could, it seems to me, quite naturally describe a building built as a town house, which had subsequently been internally converted into offices, as a 'house used as offices': hence it would 'reasonably be called' a house, even though it was not used for residential purposes."

The ruling could lead to several enfranchisement claims from commercial tenants who will see it as an opportunity to buy the freehold of their offices on favourable terms.

Nottingham could be among areas most affected as it contains so many offices situated in properties originally built as houses.

For more information please contact Peter Sutherland on 0115 988 6714 or email psutherland@andersonssolicitors.co.uk